Industry News
Lending Club Threatens The Status Quo
March 20, 2014
In late 2013, consumer peer-to-peer lender Lending Club announced their plans to start offering small business loans. That caused a stir in the merchant cash advance world for a few weeks, but the hype died down. The general consensus was that there would be little to no overlap between the applicants each target.
To this day, I continue to doubt that the overlap will be anything less than substantial. Nik Milanovic of Funding Circle would probably disagree with me. The main argument has been that Lending Club will only target small business owners with good credit, which assumes that businesses with anything less are the only users of merchant cash advances. Not to give anyone’s figures away, but I have seen data to suggest that a large segment of merchant cash advance users have FICO scores in excess of 660. Somewhere along the line we convinced ourselves that merchant cash advances were for businesses with really bad credit. That was never the purpose it was intended for, though it’s true that many applicants have low scores.
Historically, merchant cash advances were for businesses that posed a cash flow risk to banks. Split-processing eliminated that risk by withholding a percentage of card sales automatically through the payment company processing the business’s transactions. Funders today that rely on bank debits for repayment don’t have that safeguard, but they make up for the risk they take by doing something banks don’t do, require payments to be made daily instead of monthly. This allows businesses to manage their cash flow throughout the month and enables the funder to compound their earnings daily. It’s a phenomenon I wrote about in the March/April issue of DailyFunder (Razzle Dazzle Debits & Splits: Daily is the Secret Sauce)
According to the Wall Street Journal, Lending Club will require a minimum of 2 years in business and participation will initially only be open to institutional investors.
Lending Club’s website states that they will recoup funds on a monthly basis via ACH and that interest rates range from 5.9% APR to 29.9% APR + an origination fee. Terms range from 1 to 5 years and there are no early payment penalties.
TechCrunch openly pegs CAN Capital and OnDeck Capital as chief rivals for Lending Club in the space. CAN has enjoyed frontrunner status in the industry since 1998 and while they have been tested in the last 2 years, they haven’t come up against something like this.
In the same Wall Street Journal story, Lending Club’s CEO, Renaud Laplanche lays out who his competitors are with his quote, “The rates provide an alternative to short-term lenders and cash-advance companies that sometimes charge more than the equivalent of 50% annually.”
But will the impact be felt right away? In Laplanche’s interview with Fortune, he claims that it’s very likely they’ll focus on the 750+ FICO segment first, where institutional investors will be comfortable. But make no mistake about it, that will change quick, especially with a probable IPO in the next 8 months.
Is Lending Club really all that big? To draw a comparison, RapidAdvance got a $100 million enterprise valuation when they got bought out by Rockbridge Growth Equity about 6 months ago. Lending Club on the other hand was valued at around $2.3 billion at that time. It took OnDeck Capital 7 years to fund $1 Billion in loans. Lending Club is funding a billion dollars in loans every 3 and a half months. Granted, they’ve all been consumer loans, but let’s not kid ourselves about their capabilities.
Lending Club is funding more consumer loans than the entire merchant cash advance industry is doing combined. Thanks to the peer-to-peer model, they have infinity capital at their disposal. We can pretend that no one with good credit ever applied for a merchant cash advance or we can acknowledge the 3 billion pound gorilla in the room.
Lending Club and other peer-to-peer lenders that follow them will disrupt the alternative business lending status quo.
—
Previous articles on this subject:
Will Peer-to-Peer Lending Burn the Alternative Lending Market?
Lending Club Business Loans are Here
Peer-to-Peer Lending will Meet MCA Financing
Join the Industry March Madness Competition
March 11, 2014
Ready to test your NCAA basketball skills against your friends and foes? Join the industry’s 2014 March Madness Competition hosted by Merchant Cash Group! (league password: mcg589)
Merchant Cash Group will be providing a Grand Prize of $250.00* to the overall winner and keeping with tradition all participants will receive a trophy highlighting their not so stellar accomplishments.
I did really well in it last year. How well you ask? So well that Merchant Cash Group bestowed upon me this trophy:
So maybe I didn’t do so great. But I have grand plans in 2014 especially with my alma mater making the tournament for the first time since 1999. I hope you guys are ready for the Blue Hens. I have them making my final 4. Think I’m a fool? Show me up and:
———
Merchant Cash Group is a direct merchant cash advance provider and was the awesome co-host of the last 2 industry fantasy football challenges.
*You do not need to be a referral partner of MCG to participate but the Grand Prize of $250 will only be awarded to partners. Non partners will receive $100.00
Is There Cause for Alarm?
March 8, 2014
Brick and mortar chain stores died this week, after a long illness. Born along Main Street, raised in shopping malls across post-World War II America, the traditional store enjoyed decades of good health, wealth and steady growth. But in recent years its fortunes have declined. Survived by Amazon.com and online outfits too numerous to list.
– CNN 3/7/14
Just a day after Jeremy Brown’s new CEO Corner post appeared on DailyFunder with an overt bubble warning, CNN’s Chris Isidore alluded that the era of brick & mortar retail may be drawing to a close. In Isidore’s brief sensational article, he fingers an overabundance of retail space, a weak economy, and the Internet as the culprits behind Main Street‘s decline.
In the broad alternative business lending industry, the sentiment is quite the opposite. Small business demand for working capital is surging and no one is predicting anything less than stellar growth for the foreseeable future. But is the growth real?
Jeremy Brown is the CEO of Bethesda, MD-based RapidAdvance and he explains the growth may not be what it appears to be on the surface. Some cash providers are overpaying commissions, stretching out terms longer than what their risk tolerance supports, and are growing by funding businesses that have already been funded by someone else (a practice known as stacking).
If the industry collectively booked 50,000 deals in 2013 and increased that to 100,000 deals in 2014, you’d have 100% growth, or at least it would appear that way on the surface. What if the additional 50,000 deals funded this year were not new clients but rather additional advances and loans made to existing clients? It’s a lot easier to give all of your clients money twice instead of acquiring new ones.
This all begs the question, is demand for non-bank financing really growing by leaps and bounds? Or does it just appear that way because those that have already utilized it are demanding more of it?
Brown left his readers with this conclusion, “There will be a rebalancing at some point. And it will not be pretty.”
Chime in with your thoughts about this on DailyFunder.
—–
When Will the Bubble Burst? by Jeremy Brown will also appear in the next print issue of DailyFunder. If you haven’t subscribed to the magazine already, you can do so HERE.
Lending Club Business Loans are Here
January 19, 2014
As mentioned in a thread on DailyFunder, I have personally seen evidence that Lending Club is already doing business loans. The loan was issued this month in the amount of $35,000 and disbursed to a business, not an individual.
I have been very outspoken about my belief that peer-to-peer lenders will compete directly against merchant cash advance companies and their short term lending counterparts. I am now absolutely positive that will be the case as the first merchant I saw to receive a Lending Club business loan was a former user of merchant cash advances.
One has to ask themselves if Lending Club will be targeting UCCs, particularly those of their new closest competitors in the space, OnDeck Capital and NewLogic. I was not able to determine the terms of the Lending Club loan but it is still my expectation that it will be a 3-5 year deal with automated monthly payments. Compare that against the industry’s dominant short term lenders that do 1 year deals with automated daily payments.
You can argue that there will be very little overlap in the merchants these companies target but I have seen overlap right out of the gate.
I expect we’ll all see a lot more of this.
Industry Fun Leads to Charity Funds
January 15, 20142013’s alternative business financing fantasy football competition came to a close near the end of the regular NFL season. There were some tough matchups and upsets, but two Florida based companies pulled through to win it all. The league raised a total of $9,000 from its participants and as per the rules, must be donated in equal halves to non-profit organizations selected by the two winners.
Financial Advantage Group selected the Spring of Tampa Bay, a noble choice since their mission is to prevent domestic violence, protect victims and promote change in lives, families and communities. DailyFunder, the trustee of the competition reached out to the organization late last month and made the donation in a low-key manner as per their request. They did express their gratitude to Scott Williams of Financial Advantage Group on their facebook page however:
Business Financial Services selected Wounded Warrior Project. They wrote their own post about the organization and why they are proud to support that cause on their website here: http://www.businessfinancialservices.com/blog/fantasy-football-for-charity/
Wounded Warrior Project accepted their donation with some pizazz, holding a giant check for a photo-op at the organization’s Jacksonville, FL office.
—-
I personally would like to thank Heather Francis of Merchant Cash Group for being a great competition co-host this year as well all of the participants that contributed funds to make these donations possible:
- Merchant Cash Group
- Benchmark Merchant Solutions
- Yellowstone Capital
- Raharney Capital
- Strategic Funding Source
- Sure Payment Solutions
- Pearl Capital
- United Capital Source
- NVMS
- Entrust Merchant Solutions
- Financial Advantage Group
- Snap Advances
- Business Financial Services
- Integrity Payment Systems
- DailyFunder
- Capital Stack
I’m already looking forward to next season!
2014 Starts off With a Case of Red bull
January 10, 2014
Woah, slow down there fellas. Let us digest one thing at a time. We’re not even 2 weeks into the new year and already we’ve learned that:
CAN Capital raised another $33 Million (but that they didn’t need it?)
Merchant Cash Advance was the the feature story on the front page of the Wall Street Journal. Seriously…
Bloggers are learning about this industry for the first time. They’re having a bit of trouble getting it right.
PayPal, which just recently kicked off its own merchant cash advance program (or as they call it, their Working Capital Program) has already issued 4,000 advances.
Regulators are freaking out over the use of social media information in loan approvals.
DailyFunder will begin mailing out the first alternative business lending magazine a week from today. It’s free so sign up!
News from the Space
November 18, 2013
American Express recently teamed up with Heartland Payment Systems to provide split-processing loans tied to all card transactions rather than just American Express exclusively. The max loan size is $750,000. Prior to this deal American Express and other merchant cash advance companies rarely competed head-to-head. Unless a small business was processing substantial AMEX, they weren’t a candidate for American Express Merchant Financing. I expect them to make similar deals with other card processors.
Lending Club got a valuation boost with a $57 million investment from Yuri Milner’s DST Global and Coatue Management LLC. They’re now worth about $2.3 billion. They are expected to go public in 2014 which will be especially significant given their plans to enter the small business lending space as early as January. Today, alternative small business lenders worth tens of millions or hundreds of millions of dollars are the big shots in the industry. Expect major disruption if Lending Club achieves an IPO valuation in the tens of billions.
Zazma put their own spin on lending by financing the purchases small businesses make. Funds are actually wired directly to the suppliers instead of to the borrower. For now they are only doing up to $5,000 at one time, which is typically the minimum sized deal for the merchant cash advance industry.
ISO&Agent published a great article about merchant cash advance titled, Taming the Wild Frontier.
The end of the year is coming and Capital Access Network, which is now CAN Capital projects they will finish with $800 million in transactions for 2013. 15 years after they started, they are still the biggest in the business.
Merchant Cash Advance Hits Shark Tank
October 26, 2013
If you missed Friday night’s episode of Shark Tank, you absolutely must catch a rerun of it. Jason Reddish and Val Pinkhasov came on the show to pitch their merchant cash advance company, Total Merchant Resources. It was one of the best few minutes in merchant cash advance history for several reasons:
- Mark Cuban, the 213th richest man in the U.S. feared the growing popularity of expensive short term financing would invite tough government regulation.
- Kevin O’Leary understood that there were no barriers to entry and thus anyone with money can get into the industry.
- Robert Herjavec thought the capital was too expensive for small businesses.
- Kevin O’Leary said that non-bank alternative lenders like Total Merchant Resources were necessary to keep businesses afloat.
- Jason Reddish went at the Sharks like a Shark himself.
TMR walked away with a rather small 400k valuation through the deal they made with Kevin O’Leary that gave them 200k for 50% equity. It was O’Leary’s claim that his connections and capital would blow the lid off their business that was too good to pass up.
O’Leary had a compelling argument for why his terms were non-negotiable. Anyone can be in this business. The valuation itself was moot because two guys with a relatively small operation just became partners with a famous venture capitalist worth $300 million. Had I been in their circumstances, I would’ve taken the deal as well.
O’Leary’s name in the space makes TMR relevant and a company to watch out for, but they are by no means guaranteed success. They are up against much deeper pockets. Dan Gilbert, the 126th richest man in the U.S. owns RapidAdvance (through Rockbridge Growth Equity), a firm that got an enterprise valuation of over $100 million. Google and Peter Thiel have their hand in On Deck Capital. Google also has a stake in Lending Club, a peer-to-peer lender worth $1.55 billion that threatens to disrupt the alternative business loan market with their new loan product come early 2014. Capital Access Network funds nearly three quarters of a billion dollars a year. Every day another power player swoops in and raises the stakes, putting O’Leary in a position he’s probably not used to being in himself, in the shark tank.
At the end of the day, there are a lot of profitable ISOs and small funders. Pinkhasov and Reddish did what no one else to date has done, gone on TV and pitched Mark Cuban on merchant cash advance. And for that, they will go down in history. We’ll follow their story as it develops and I invite them to e-mail me if they’d like to comment.
You can follow the thread about their appearance on the show and find the link to the video on DailyFunder.
