Business Lending
B2B Finance at deBanked
July 5, 2024
When Broker Fair first debuted in 2018, the keynote speaker was none other than Ryan Serhant, then a fast rising New York City real estate broker and star of Bravo’s Million Dollar Listing. Today he’s got his own Netflix Series called Owning Manhattan.
“After selling real estate for 12 years, I decided to start my own company,” Serhant says in the trailer for the first episode, “and if you can’t sell, you can’t be here.”
That New York hustle attitude was the connecting link for why Broker Fair chose him despite the broker audience being largely engaged in small business financial services at the time. But since then the small business finance broker community has become increasingly diversified in its product offerings and real estate is frequently one of the assets on the menu.
“People will be surprised how many clients have real estate, not just a [primary home], but they own just a small multifamily down the road that they never touched or tapped into,” said Julio Sencion, Principal at Alta Financial, in a recent interview with deBanked.
Companies like World Business Lenders figured that out a long time ago while still more discovered the business during the covid recovery, leading deBanked to produce a video miniseries about real estate investing in the summer of 2021. The guests ranged from real estate influencer Ralph DiBugnara to NestSeekers International’s Chief Economist Erin Sykes to a couple of old fashioned guys named Danny and Bruce who started investing in real estate across New Jersey long ago.
deBanked also interviewed house-flipper turned real estate tech CEO Andrew Luong of Doorvest, did a deep dive as to why real estate was becoming the side hustle of choice in the industry, and even bought real land using the blockchain for the purpose of a story.
Equipment financing has also taken off, leading deBanked to produce the first ever sales reality series named Equipping The Dream in 2022.
That’s been complemented by regular coverage and even sitdown interviews from Andrew Carman, Steve Geller, and George A. Parker.
deBanked’s Sean Murray has previously presented at the International Factoring Association’s (IFA) Fintech educational event, been a guest on the Coleman Report run by renowned SBA expert Bob Coleman, and moderated panels separately for the New York Institute of Credit and the Alternative Finance Bar Association.
Murray was also the host and producer of the industry’s first ever Broker Battle which took placed in Miami Beach this past January.
deBanked is also affiliated with the largest online small business finance community in the US, DailyFunder, and has produced nearly two dozen events since 2017.
“Back in 2018, there was a question that Serhant posed on stage to the Broker Fair audience to make sure he understood where they were coming from,” Murray said. “‘You guys are all B2B right?’ he said, and I think his characterization was spot on, because B2B is pretty much what we’ve been all along.”
deBanked is collaborating with the Small Business Finance Association on the B2B Finance Expo that’s taking place in Las Vegas on September 23-24. For info, visit: https://www.b2bfinexpo.com
Smart Business Funding Prevails in Trademark Lawsuit
July 3, 2024Smart Business Funding, the trademark owned by Collins Cash Inc, has officially survived a trademark infringement challenge brought by BillFloat Inc dba SmartBiz. Both companies began using their respective marks a decade ago and the two even had a partnership referral agreement at one point. However, in 2020, SmartBiz sent Smart Business Funding a Cease & Desist letter on the basis that it was allegedly infringing on its mark and causing confusion in the market. While they are both engaged in small business financing, each offers different products. SmartBiz eventually filed a lawsuit.
After the original trial went in favor of Smart Business Funding, the decision was re-examined on appeal. There, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the original ruling. The Smart Business Funding mark does not infringe upon SmartBiz.
Company Acquiring Funding Circle USA Had Previously Acquired Knight Capital and Assets of Fountainhead
June 24, 2024
iBusiness Funding, LLC, which is acquiring Funding Circle’s US arm, is no stranger to the small business finance industry. That’s because the company not only acquired select assets of Fountainhead SBF LLC last year, but its parent company, Ready Capital, had also acquired Knight Capital in 2019.
Ready Capital, a non-bank SBA lender, had also been one of the largest PPP lenders in the country during the pandemic. The designation of being an SBA lender is a highlight in the acquisition of Funding Circle because it means it does not need Funding Circle’s SBLC license to do SBA loans. Funding Circle had faced hostility by members of congress earlier this year for exploring a sale of its business only after it had lobbied for and finally secured an SBLC license. Now the matter is moot.
“As the Ready Capital group already holds an SBLC license, Funding Circle has, with SBA consent, surrendered its SBLC license,” the announcement by Funding Circle said. “The transaction is expected to close by the end of June.”
It was a share purchase agreement for a total cash consideration of £33 million ($42 million) which includes all of the company’s loan portfolios.
Funding Circle CEO Lisa Jacobs said, “We are pleased to have reached an agreement with iBusiness Funding, one of the leading processors of loans to US small businesses. In iBusiness, we have found a partner that shares in our mission, and we look forward to seeing the success of the combined entity.”
Ready Capital CEO Thomas Capasse said, “We’re excited to acquire FC USA and expect the acquisition to yield meaningful revenue and earnings to the combined company in the years to come.”
Founder and CEO of iBusiness Funding LLC Justin Levy said, “We are thrilled to welcome the exceptional FC USA team to the iBusiness family. FC USA’s mission to be the largest SBA lender for loans under $500,000 aligns with our goal to support underserved borrowers, the only difference is iBusiness achieves this goal through many SBA-approved lenders in our network.”
SBA Direct Lending Plan Not Likely to Happen
June 19, 2024A proposal to allow the SBA to get into the direct lending business appears to have been taken off the table. Originally, the president’s FY 2025 budget plan called for the SBA to get into direct lending “to address gaps in access to small dollar lending.” However, in the budget introduced by The House Committee on Appropriations this week, the Committee added a provision that would prohibit the SBA from “creating, implementing, administering, expanding, or enforcing a direct lending program that was not already in effect on January 1, 2024.” The Committee is chaired by Republican Tom Cole.
SellersFi Surpasses $1B in Loans Since Inception, Experiences Success Through E-Commerce Funding
June 14, 2024The timing of it all was fortuitous for SellersFi. When the company announced in January that it had secured a partnership with Amazon to provide eligible Amazon sellers with access to credit lines, it was clear that its fresh equity raise and credit facility of up to $300 million were going to be put to use. SellersFi wasn’t the only partner, however, and Amazon still did most of the lending to its own sellers directly, a business it had been in for more than a decade, but it was still a big relationship to have. But then it got better. In March, Amazon announced that it would end its direct lending program and rely entirely on its partners instead. For SellersFi that meant it would have the opportunity to service even more sellers on the platform than before. Since then, SellersFi has quietly surpassed $1 billion in loans since inception.
“What we are seeing now is less competition,” said Ricardo Pero, CEO of SellersFi, in a call with deBanked. He partially attributed that to the current interest rate environment which has impacted those with small margins. SellersFi, however, has experienced a lot of success. The company knows the e-commerce space particularly well, the only space it operates in, since its the only US lending platform also approved as a payment service provider member for Amazon. They started their relationship with Amazon as a service provider 3 years ago. While Pero said they have seen “nothing that points to a recession,” their experience suggests that even if one were to happen in the future, consumers would react by seeking out bargains on e-commerce platforms, reinforcing their position as the niche to be in. As readers may recall, a flight to e-commerce is also what happened during the pandemic.
E-commerce, however, is a broad umbrella, and Amazon is not alone in the universe. Millions of businesses rely on various platforms for e-commerce from basic templates with API connections to Shopify and more. Even big box brick and mortar retailers are waking up and rapidly inching their way into e-commerce. Walmart is just one example, which not only accommodates individual sellers on its platform but also offers merchant cash advances to them.
“The competitive landscape is changing for our clients,” Pero said. Pero added that they know what’s going on because they talk to these clients all the time and that even in the e-commerce business there are person-to-person relationships. “Customers mention their account managers by name,” Pero said. “We have a reputation as a partner to these merchants.”
One trend they’ve noticed over the last year or so is their strategy towards borrowing. While merchants have always typically used funds for things like advertising or inventory, the previous low rate environment enabled behavior where merchants could borrow first and then figure out how to spend the funds second whereas now that rates are higher there is a lot more of a deliberative approach to precisely how much they should get and what it will be used for in advance. It’s something they see all the time now and agree with. “You need to plan,” Pero said.
Looking at PayPal’s Business Funding Charge-Offs
June 10, 2024
When PayPal announced a sudden and dramatic pullback on its MCA and business loan operations in the third quarter of 2023, it was surprising news. For instance, the company’s net charge-off rate had been trending downward for years, coming in 7.4% at year-end 2019 right before covid and going down to 4.7% in 2021 and down to 4.5% in 2022. By June 2023, however, that number had somehow soared to 13.3% and by September was 20.4%. At the time, PayPal attributed this shift to “the expansion of acceptable risk parameters in 2022, which resulted in a decline in the overall credit quality of loans outstanding.” Because of how they calculate charge-offs, reducing originations at the same time that charge-offs were peaking made that number look a bit worse than it was. But still…
Although many funding and lending companies have complained of an increase in fraudulent applications in the immediate post-covid era, PayPal’s figures can hardly be attributed to fraud. That’s because their charge-off rate doesn’t even include losses from fraud.
PayPal’s products are very short-term so it was able to rapidly scale back its balance sheet exposure. Total merchant advances and loans outstanding, net of participation interest sold, decreased from $2.1B in Q1 2023 down to $1.2B in Q1 2024. Of the active loans, 88.7% were considered current in Q1 and 4.4% were greater than 90 days beyond their projected payment pace. With the exception of 2020 (when the % > 90 days past expected hit 12.5%), 4.4% is among the worst PayPal has experienced since 2017.
Trading MCA for Mortgages
June 5, 2024
“I like multiple ways of getting business,” said Julio Sencion, Principal at Alta Financial. “If I did one thing and one thing only and that slows down, it affects my bottom line, so I like to keep my doors open for more opportunity and I think the ISOs should as well.”
Sencion’s not funding MCAs today, he’s doing mortgages, a business he had been in for years prior to the Great Recession. In the early 2000s, he said that everyone wanted to be a mortgage broker, himself included when he got into it. Like many in that business at the time, the fallout of it all pushed him to seek out a new revenue stream and a product that was still in demand. By 2011 he and a partner were running a large MCA brokerage shop in New York with nearly 70 sales reps on the floor. Sencion liked the business but not necessarily the conversion rates on the leads he was buying. By his count only 2-3% of the leads would become a funded deal, a metric deemed too low in the industry era of yesteryear. Old habits die hard, however, because he couldn’t help but continue to think like a mortgage guy.
“We realized that we had a couple of different questions on our application, one of them was ‘Do you own real estate? Commercial, residential?’ 40 to 50% of our clients owned real estate, so because of that we spun off a division for commercial lending.”
By 2016 Sencion exited MCA and went back into traditional finance. He’s now a principal at Alta Financial, which not only does mortgages but has also found a unique niche to source borrowers from, MCA brokers.
“So let’s say for example you’re an ISO and the client says ‘yes, I own real estate’ I’ll be interested in looking at that product,” Sencion said. “Then you will click a link that we will give you, that link will open up the questionnaire and you will fill out that questionnaire and then my agent will receive that lead from that questionnaire with all the data in it.”
Referrals of this nature in the biz are not new, but perhaps the circumstances are. One of Sencion’s account managers, Jamie Schiff, is also a former MCA rep himself, and he’s found this business to be better.
“I think over the past a year and a half, from my perspective, I think the MCA space is just a bit saturated,” said Schiff. “There’s a million and one funders out there.”
The challenge with this different product, according to Schiff, is getting an MCA broker to wrap their mind around a deal that could take a month to close when they might be used to 2-3 days. But on the upside Alta Financial does all the work and they really just want a broker to qualify a lead and submit the details. If a loan closes the broker gets paid. Quite a number of MCA broker shops are already doing this with them, the company said. Once these files are in hand, they underwrite various factors including credit score of the borrower. While just about any kind of property could qualify except for gas stations, they said that multifamily properties are the most common they get.
“People will be surprised how many clients have real estate, not just a [primary home], but they own just a small multifamily down the road that they never touched or tapped into,” said Sencion. “So I think it’s important nowadays to have the ISOs ask the question because if they didn’t do the cash advance they could always flip this into a mortgage.”
While all of Alta’s loans are secured by real estate, they can look beyond the value of the asset by evaluating an applicant on the rental income they generate or look at the average revenue from their business bank statements and base a loan amount off of that. Naturally, the rates and terms are much more attractive than what’s available in the unsecured market. There’s also the added benefit of these products being able to work alongside an MCA or to buy out existing ones. It’s a commission a broker might not have gotten otherwise.
“I’m actually excited, it’s something different but it’s kind of the same,” said Schiff. “And it’s such a smaller space that I don’t have to worry about every other month 10 other new funders popping up…”
As for Sencion, he said that the barriers to entry are higher than the MCA business, between the education, state licensing, how to process the files, etc.
“It takes years to get to the level of where we’re at, to be able to underwrite, fund deals, sell to a secondary market,” said Sencion. “And I think that’s where the edge comes in, you can’t get a cash advance guy, no matter how big they are, to get into my space unless they team up with a mortgage company. No one’s out there trying to become a mortgage company anymore like it was back then.”
Kris Roglieri To Stay in Prison Indefinitely After Shocking Development
June 3, 2024Add credible threats to murder an FBI agent to the list of scandalous accolades that Kris Roglieri has racked up in recent months. On Monday, prosecutors revealed the rationale behind the unusual demand to have him detained for what is seemingly a white collar crime, and that is that he has become dangerous. According to calls and emails Roglieri had with an unnamed friend, he said would “take out” a judge and a receiver, that he was going to “wack anybody” that went after him, and that he had determined the home address of one of the FBI agents investigating him and that he planned to put a bullet in their head.
“when someone takes everything away from you . . . if I go down, everyone goes down,” he said.
When the FBI became fully aware of the circumstances, he was arrested and taken into custody on May 31 on a single charge of wire fraud. It is likely that more charges will follow given that more than $100 million of the funds he took from customers remain unaccounted for. Nevertheless, prosecutors used the danger he posed to secure his temporary detainment without bail and on Monday he was ordered to remain in prison indefinitely while awaiting trial. He is being represented by a public defender.
Meanwhile, Roglieri’s company Prime Capital Ventures has been in receivership while he himself is in Chapter 7. In the latter case, he was recently ordered to turn over all his assets, including ownership of his businesses. One of those businesses, NACLB, announced prior to the order that it was rebranding to a different name, was still accepting payments from customers, and that it was exciting to still be moving forward.
