Clicky

  • Welcome to P2P Lending / NFT Lending Forum.
 

ETH.LOAN

News:

This was the original Lend Academy peer-to-peer lending forum, since forensically restored by deBanked and now reintroduced to eth.loan.

To restore access to your user account, email [email protected]. We apologize for errors you may experience during the recovery.

Main Menu
NEW LOANS:   | 870.eth 2.500 Ξ | 804.eth 2.500 Ξ | remoraid.eth 0.299 Ξ | ALL

Cancelled notes: any analysis on those

Started by Peter, October 21, 2013, 11:00:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kombinator

Wanted to see if anyone has done any analysis on some parameters that cause notes that pass all the screens and get funded to be ultimately not originated by the platform. 

Seems this ratio is very steady at about 32% of total notes / dollars committed month after month, and so far I have not ben able to explain it.  It is clearly creating a cash drag, so I wonder if anyone has managed to keep a better ratio of invested to originated on a stable basis, and if so is there a criteria that affects this in a meaningful fashion?

maxdriver

What are you using for loan filters? My cancellation rate is much lower.

avid investor

I suspect that the cancellation rate goes up roughly with the interest rate.  Underwriting would look for more information from the borrower, the borrower doesn't bother to provide it, or when they do, it doesn't support approval of the loan, and it is cancelled.

TravelingPennies

That actually seems to make sense, I guess as a side effect of higher rate loans, they are higher risk and lower reliability, which is causing a larger percentage of them to not bother to provide or verify documentation in the end and thus lead to high cancellation rates on the order of 32%.

rawraw

In my experience, my DEFG notes have a much higher "return to lender" ratio than my ABC

AnilG

For loans listed between Sept 1st and 7th 2013

Credit Grade = A
% Loans Not Issued = 28%

Credit Grade = B
% Loans Not Issued = 32%

Credit Grade = C
% Loans Not Issued = 41%

Credit Grade = D
% Loans Not Issued = 49%

Credit Grade = E
% Loans Not Issued = 56%

Credit Grade = F
% Loans Not Issued = 58%

Credit Grade = G
% Loans Not Issued = 52%


TravelingPennies

Great, Anil wonderful data, thank you, very helpful.

Would you be able to share just how and where you obtained the data that allowed you to run the above analysis, unlike prosper cancelled loans don't stay in the notes.csv file, so hard to be able to track them on account level.  Don't know if that is doable, but if not, how are you tracking them even on population level, is there a field that can be used?

brycemason

He's saving all the browseNotes files. Good job, Anil. I've definitely experienced a larger proportion of As and Bs getting issued than my higher risk portfolio.

TravelingPennies

Longitudinal data collection with PeerCube and some transformation for finding the answer.

https://forum.lendacademy.com/index.php?topic=1692.msg13940#msg88888888Quote"> from: Kombinator on November 02, 2013, 10:48:48 AM

lascott

I don't think it is my imagination but in the past few weeks I have noticed a LOT more notes going through and less being canceled. Others notice anything? ie. the info I get in these emails"
- Order complete: # Note(s) not issued
- Order complete: All Notes issued

Aside: I had a thread on this canceled notes percentage topic ( http://www.lendacademy.com/forum/index.php?topic=2296.0" class="bbc_link" target="_blank">http://www.lendacademy.com/forum/index.php?topic=2296.0 ) and Anil ponited me to this older one.

https://forum.lendacademy.com/index.php?topic=1692.msg13936#msg88888888Quote"> from: AnilG on November 02, 2013, 02:30:48 AM

TravelingPennies

Table 2 in my blog post at https://www.peercube.com/blog/post/21" class="bbc_link" target="_blank">https://www.peercube.com/blog/post/21 has better number on loans issued as percentage of loans listed.

https://forum.lendacademy.com/index.php?topic=1692.msg21006#msg88888888Quote"> from: lascott on July 12, 2014, 11:30:08 AM

NEW LOANS:   | 870.eth 2.500 Ξ | 804.eth 2.500 Ξ | remoraid.eth 0.299 Ξ | ALL